South Dakota Supreme Court October 18, 1920, File No. 4751 (Dalton v. Snyder)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-10-1920

WHITING, J.

Plaintiff entered into a written contract whereby he covenanted to sell and convey to defendant certain lands in this state. Alleging that this contract was procured through the fraud of defendant plaintiff brought this action, setting forth what he alleged t0‘ have been the oral agreement and the acts of fraud which he alleged were practiced upon him caus*404ing him to become a party to a contract different from said oral agreement. In his prayer for relief, as the same appears in the printed record, he asks that said contract “be canceled and annulled and held for naught, and vacated and set aside, and that in event perpetrated to vitiate the said contract, that the same be reformed in keeping with the understanding of the parties, if such could be ascertained, * * * ” It is apparent that there was an error in the use of the word “perpetrated” in copying the prayer for relief into the printed record, but we deem' it clear that plaintiff prayed for alternative relief, cancellation of the written contract, or, in lieu of cancellation, if the court denied that relief, reformation of such contract. Defendant denied the charge of fraud, alleged partial performance, offered, full performance, and prayed specific performance of contract. Trial was had to the court without a jury. Findings, .conclusions, and judgment were in favor of defendant, and plaintiff has appealed from the judgment and from an order denying a new trial.

[1] Appellant has assigned errors in the admission of evidence and specifies particularly wherein he claims that the evidence fails to support the findings. That there was no prejudicial error in the rulings upon admission of evidence is too clear to admit of discussion, and the assignments in relation thereto present no question meriting our further consideration. The clear preponderance of the evidence supports the findings of the trial court.

There is practically no dispute as to the facts except upon one point.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.