North Dakota Supreme Court September 25, 1920 (Jessen v. Schiller)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-09-1920
Bronson, J.
This is an appeal from a garnishment judgment in favor of the plaintiffs upon findings made by the district court. The proceedings necessary to be stated are as follows: A civil action to recover $38.50, accompanied with garnishment proceedings, 'was instituted in justice’s court. The return day fixed in both the summons and garnishee summons was September 5, 1919, at 8 a. m. On the return day, about 10:30 a. u., upon proceedings had, judgment was rendered in the main action against the defendants for $49.65. As the record of the justice discloses, the garnishment proceedings were held open subject to the outcome of the main action. The justice’s record then recites as follows:
“Now, at 10:30 a. m. the garnishee by J. E. Eklund, Vice Presi*43dent, admits liability to the defendant John Schiller in the sum of $120. Now, at 10:30 a. m. the defendant John Schiller appears by his Attorneys, Jacobsen & Murray, and files written answer and claim for ■exemption, including schedule of his personal property. To which the plaintiff objects as insufficient, not having been filed at or before the time set for appearance of the garnishee. The court, after the claim, finds that it was not in time and therefore denies the claim. Judgment is hereby entered against the garnishee, Bresden-Larson Lumber Company, a corporation, for the sum of $49.40 and costs.”
Thereafter, the defendant John Schiller appealed from this garnishment judgment to the district court. Later, before the Honorable J. M. Hanley, District Judge, a motion for dismissal of the appeal, upon the grounds that the claim for exemption was not made in due form and in time, was denied and the cause set for trial by the court. Subsequently, the Honorable li. T. Lemblce, Distinct Judge, tried the action and made the findings of the court to the effect that the claim for exemption was not in due form and was filed too late. From the judgment rendered upon such findings the defendant John Schiller has appealed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit