North Dakota Supreme Court December 11, 1920 (Schantz v. Northern Pacific Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-12-1920

lead-opinion

Grace, J.

This appeal is from a judgment in favor of defendant, dismissing the action, upon a general verdict in favor of the plaintiff, in connection with which verdict special interrogatories were returned.

The complaint states an action against the defendant for personal injuries, under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, U. S. Comp, Stat. §§ 8657-8665. A general verdict was returned in favor of tho plaintiff for $7,500. The only question involved in this appeal is whether the special findings destroyed the general verdict.

The following are the special interrogatories and the answers, where answer was made:

Question 1: Did Raphael Schantz know, or should he, in the exercise of reasonable care, have known, that he might be injured if he attempted to catch the moving freight train?

Answer: He should have known.

Question 2: Did the father and mother of Raphael Schantz suffer any actual, pecuniary or money loss because of Raphael’s death ?

Answer: -

Question 3: If you answer the preceding question in the affirmative, what is the amount of that loss ?

Answer: -

Question 4: Was the proximate or real cause of Raphael Schantz’s death the injury received at Harmon?

Answer: No.

*4Question 5: What is the damage suffered because o± pain and suffering endured by Eaphael Schantz ?

Answer: $7,500.

Question 6: Was the injury received by Eaphael Schantz, at Harmon, an accident for which no one in particular is to blame ?

Answer: No.

Subsequent to the return of the general verdict, the defendant made a motion for judgment on the special questions answered by the jury. The court granted the motion, and ordered judgment in favor of the defendant for a dismissal of the action on its merits, and for costs and disbursements, and judgment was entered accordingly.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.