Supreme Court of Virginia June 10, 1920 (Town of Farmville v. Wells)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-06-1920
Burks, J.,
delivered the opinion of the court.
Mrs. Wells (the defendant in error) recovered a judgment against the town of Farmville for §1,000 damages for injury to her property occasioned by throwing surface water back on her premises.
The following errors are assigned in the petition for a writ of error: (1) Overruling the demurrer to the declaration, (2) refusing to grant a continuance, (3) refusing to set aside the verdict as contrary to the law and the evidence, (4) granting instructions for the plaintiff, and (5) refusing to grant instructions for the defendant. There was not only abundant evidence to support the verdict, but the decided preponderance of the evidence was in favor of the finding. So that the verdict could only be set aside, if at all, because it was contrary to the law. It would not be useful or edifying to discuss the assignments of error seriatim, as all of them except No. 2 on the subject of the continuance, involve the application of the law on the subject of surface water to the facts of the case.
*530There is some conflict in the evidence as to the conditions on the plaintiff’s premises, but this is settled by the verdict of the jury. The case, as made by a preponderance of the evidence, supported by said verdict, is as follows: Mrs. Wells owned a house and lot situate on Pine street in the town of Farmville. Her yard was on grade with Pine street. The house was a comfortable dwelling house, with one cellar room underneath, which was “a good nicely whitewashed, clean, comfortable cellar,” with a'floor in it, and it was used for a cook room and dining room. The lot was cultivated as a garden. It was the. lowest lot on the block, and the other lots above and around it drained through this garden to and across Pine street. In passing through the garden the water is said to have “a natural drainage all through the garden,” there was “a channel through Mrs. Wells’ property.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit