Oregon Supreme Court December 14, 1920 (Johnston v. Apple)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-12-1920
JOHNS, J.
1-3. This is an equitable proceeding, which, under the statute, is tried de novo here, and in the Circuit Court upon the record made in the County Court. The execution of the note being admitted, the only question presented is one of payment, and the burden of proof is upon the heirs of the deceased. The testimony is conclusive that soon after its execution the note was assigned by Apple as collateral to the Northwestern National Bank, where it remained until the 6th of January, 1916, during which time the three interest payments were made by C. M. Hollopeter. On that date the bank delivered the note to Apple, who has had actual possession of it ever since. Attorney Bannon testified that Apple exhibited the note to him at the time he prepared his petition to be appointed administrator of the estate of Eunice E. Hollopeter, which was soon after her death in August, 1916. That would entitle him to the statutory presumption under Section 799, Or. L., “that things in the possession of a person are owned by him, ’ ’ that is to say, the law presumes that Apple was then the owner and holder of the note. After hearing the testimony in open court, the county judge found that the claim should be allowed. He saw and heard the witnesses testify, and in.this kind of a case his finding is entitled to some weight. The Circuit Court found, as a fact, that “after the death of C. M. Hollopeter, said note was not paid by Eunice E. Hollopeter, deceased,” and there is no evidence that she ever paid the note, or ever claimed to have paid it. If the note was ever paid, it was paid by C. M. Hollopeter. The testimony is conclusive that soon after the execution of the note it was assigned, as collateral, to the bank, where it remained until *283January 6, 1916. It appears that Dr. Hollopeter died December 30, 1915. Claudia A., the daughter-in-law of Dr. and Eunice E. Hollopeter, testified:
“Q. Do you not know that for mere than a year prior to his death, Dr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit