Illinois Supreme Court December 21, 1920, No. 13486 (Rockford City Traction Co. v. Industrial Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-12-1920

Mr. Justice Thompson

delivered the opinion of the court:

Defendant in error was employed by plaintiff in- error as a welder. In the latter part of May, 1918, while he was welding rails he' suffered an injury which has resulted in the total loss of the use of both eyes. In welding rails defendant in. error operated an electric welder which used about 550 volts of electricity. The welder is applied to the ends of the rails as they are laid in the track, the purpose being to melt the steel and thereby cause the rails to join. In doing this a dazzling light is generated and it is necessary for the welder to protect his eyes with colored glasses. For this .purpose plaintiff in error provided defendant in error with a hood which had in it a double thickness of colored glass,—one red and the other green.' Because of the excessive heat or a piece of molten metal coming in contact with the glass, or for some other unexplained reason, one set of these glasses broke and dropped out and defendant in error received the flash of light on his naked eyes. He jumped back from his work, but for some minutes his sight was blurred to such an extent that he could not see. After a few minutes’ rest his sight returned and he replaced the broken lenses and in about thirty minutes returned to his work. His sight gradually failed him until he was no longer able to work. On application to the Industrial Commission compensation was awarded, and on certiorari to the circuit court of Winnebago county the award of the commission was confirmed. This writ of error is prosecuted to review that judgment.

Much of the evidence appearing in the record tends to show that the loss of sight is not due to the accident but to the existence of a pre-existing disease. Defendant in error was thirty-three years of age and up to the time of the accident had never had any trouble with his eyes. About two years before this accident Dr. W. G.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.