Indiana Court of Appeals April 28, 1920, No. 10,267 (Massachusetts Bonding & Insurance v. State ex rel. Black)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-04-1920

Enloe, J.

This suit was brought by James Black, as relator, upon a contractor’s bond, executed by the appellees Case and Fentress, as principals, aiid by appellant as surety thereon.

The complaint was in one paragraph, to which the appellant unsuccessfully demurred. It then filed answer in six paragraphs, to the third, fourth, fifth and sixth of which demurrers were sustained. A reply in general denial to the second paragraph of answer closed the issues, which were submitted to the court for trial, resulting in a finding and judgment in favor of said relator. Its motion for a new trial having been overruled, appellant prosecutes this appeal and has assigned error which require a consideration of the questions herein determined.

Appellant first insists that the complaint was insufficient, because it failed to show any consideration for the execution of the bond in suit.

The complaint alleged: “That the said Fentress and Case paid the defendant surety company a valuable con*18sideration for its execution of said bond.” It also alleged that plaintiff, “relying upon said bond did work and labor for said defendants, Fentress and Case,” in the construction of said road. The bond, which as an. exhibit was made a part of the complaint, also recites that, “the Board of Commissioners, of Martin County have let a contract * * *;” and the complaint alleges that “said contract was entered into December 6th, 1915,” while the bond in suit appears to have been executed by appellant December 30, 1915, and approved by the board .of commissioners February 7, 1916.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.