Court of Appeals of Kentucky February 3, 1920 (Phillips v. Murphy & Gary)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-02-1920
Opinion of the Court by
Judge Settle —
Affirming.
It appears from the averments of the petition in this case that Sarah E. Lile and Mary J. Lile, elderly unmarried sisters, each owned a parcel of land in Muhlenberg county, that of the former containing 72 acres, that of the latter 58 acres, which they obtained by devise or inheritance through the death of Mark Lile, a bachelor brother. The tracts, adjoined and as the 58 acre tract of Mary J. Lile contained no buildings and the 72 acre tract of Sarah E. Lile the dwelling house and other buildings which had been occupied by the former owner of both parcels of land, the sisters both resided practically the remainder of their respective lives on the 72 acre tract, obtaining a joint support from the two tracts and sharing in common the rents and profits derived from their cultivation. While thus residing together each of the sisters executed a will. By that of Sarah E. Lile the 72 acres of land, of which she was the owner, was. devised to her sister, Mary J. Lile, for life with remainder in fee simple, at her death, to the children of their brother, Thomas J. Lile. By the will of Mary J. Lile, the 58 acres of land owned by her was devised to her sister, Sarah *765E. Lile, for life with remainder in fee simple, at her death, to the children of their brother, Joe M. Lile.
The wills bear date August 12, 1896. Sarah E. Lile died in 1912. Mary J. Lile in 1913, and the will of each was admitted to probate by the Mulilenberg county court shortly after her death. It turned out however that neither testatrix at the time of her death had title to the land devised by her will; the 72 acre tract of Sarah E. Lile having by deed executed in 1909 been conveyed by her to Willie Lile, a great nephew; and the 58 acre tract of Mary J. Lile sold and, by deed of January 25, 1909, conveyed by her to one Jesse Murphy, who, by deed of December 24, 1910, sold and conveyed it to Will Gary.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit