Court of Appeals of Kentucky April 20, 1920 (City of Georgetown v. Pullen)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-04-1920

Opinion op the Court by

Judge Sampson

Beversing.

The city of Georgetown brought this action to annex certain described territory and bring it within that municipality’s jurisdiction. Practically all of the real property owners - living in the territory proposed to be annexed remonstrated against the annexation in the manner provided by section 3483 Kentucky Statutes. The city council passed the necessary ordinances and each step in the proceeding was regular. Those opposed to (he annexation filed an answer containing seven paragraphs, asserting the following defenses to the proceeding to annex-:

(1) A plea of res judicata, there having been a suit, between the same parties for the same purpose, covering exactly the same territory, instituted and decided adversely to the plaintiff city only a few years before.

*698(2) That all of the residents of the district proposed to be annexed, opposed the annexation, and the city does not propose to render any service whatever to such residents if the territory is annexed.

(3) That the territory proposed to be annexed is not so located as to be suitable for city purposes, streets, etc.

(4) That there are hundreds of vacant lots within the present city limits and that there has not been a single building erected in the city for many months, and no necessity for taking in additional territory.

(5) The city is unable to pave or macadamize the streets already within its limits, and therefore would be unable to take care of new streets.

(6) The sale value of the property proposed to be included would be greatly decreased.

(7) That the town is not growing in population but decreasing, and as there was no cause shown for the annexation in the first suit, and the town is now smaller in population than then, no cause can be shown for annexation now.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.