Court of Appeals of Kentucky November 16, 1920 (Craig v. Security Producing & Refining Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-11-1920
Opinion op the Court by
Judge Sampson
Affirming.
The Security Producing’ and Refining Company, a corporation, was assessed by. the state tax commission and paid into the state treasury as license tax $750.00, for the year 1918, and a like amount for the year 1919, under sections 4189a and 4189 c, Kentucky Statutes, and is now-suing and is granted a mandamus by the lower court against the auditor, requiring him to draw bis warrant on the state treasury for the $1,500.00 paid by it as tax when no license tax wa,s due by said company at that time on this account. The auditor is prosecuting this appeal. Section 162 Kentucky Statutes provides: “When it shall appear to the auditor that money has been paid into the treasury for taxes when no such taxes were in fact due, he shall issue his warrant on the treasury for such money so improperly paid, in behalf of tbe person who paid the same. Nothing herein contained shall authorize the issuing of any such warrant in favor of any person who may have made payment of -the revenue tax due on any tract of land, unless it is manifest that the whole of the tax due the Commonwealth on such land has been paid, independent of the mistaken payment, and ought to be reimbursed. ’ ’ In construing this section of the statutes wo held in Greene, Auditor v. Taylor, 184 Ky. 739, “that taxes, voluntarily paid to counties, cities, towns and county officers, ■collecting the-state’s revenues and other collecting officers, • can not be recovered although not due, and paid under a mistake of law. City of Louisville v. Anderson, 79 Ky. 334; L. & N. R. R. Co. v. Hopkins Co., 87 Ky. 605; L. & N. R. R. Co. v. Commonwealth, 89 Ky. 531.
It is conceded that the Security Producing & Refining Company, paid, through mistake of law, the taxes for 1918 and 1919 under sections 4189a and 4189c, when it was required to and did pay to the state a license tax equal to one per centum of the market value of the crude petroleum produced by it.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit