Court of Appeals of Kentucky November 19, 1920 (Cincinnati, New Orleans & Texas Pacific Ry. Co. v. Depot Lunch Room)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-11-1920

Opinion op the Court by

Judge Quin

Reversing.

March 6, 1912, appellant on the one part and M. 0. Lowell and 0. T. Lowell on the other, -entered into a contract by the terms of which appellant agreed to erect a one story building on its premises south of its passenger depot at Danville, Ky., to enable the Lowells to conduct a restaurant in said building.

At the time of the present litigation the rights under this contract were by successive assignments held by appellee. The lease was for a term of five years from and after the completion of the building, a rental of $50.00 to be paid monthly in advance. The building was completed about August 1,1912, continuously from which date a restaurant has been conducted in said building by the' Lowells and their assignees.

Alleging appellees were wrongfully withholding from it the possession of said building appellant instituted this action to obtain the possession of its property and for damages for the retention thereof.

*123June 29, 1918, appellant served notice on appellee to vacate the premises by July 31, 1918. An answer made up the issues. Upon a trial of the action the court overruled appellant’s motion for a directed verdict but sustained a like motion made by appellee, and this appeal is to reverse the judgment entered pursuant to that ruling’.

Geo. T. Weatherford and Dr.. T. R. Griffin, two of appellee’s stockholders, testified in substance that in the summer of 1916, Griffin went to Weatherford who at that time was postmaster at Hustonville, and urged him to buy an interest in the lunch room, informing him that W. T. Caldwell, appellant’s superintendent, said there would be no difficulty in securing a renewal of the lease for an additional five years. Thereafter Weatherford went to Danville, and in company with Griffin, called upon Mr. Caldwell, who told them there .would be no trouble about renewing the lease. Acting upon this assurance Weatherford purchased an interest in the lunch room.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.