Supreme Court of Arkansas May 10, 1920 (Chas. F. Luehrmann Hardwood Lumber Co. v. Coats & Green)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-05-1920
Smith, J.
Appellant is a corporation, with its situs in St. Louis, Missouri, and is a dealer in lumber. Appellees were a copartnership, and owned and operated a sawmill at Ponder’s Switch, about six miles east of Hoxie on the Frisco railroad. Appellant and appellees entered into a contract in writing on June 6, 1917, whereby appellees, for a priece there specified, agreed to saw for appellant 400,000 feet of gum lumber. The contract contained the following provisions:
“To begin cutting by 1st of July, and complete the order in three months. Lumber to remain on sticks, from 90 to 120 days, or as ordered loaded by C. F. Luehrmann Hardwood Lumber Company.
‘ ‘ This order to be followed up with regular stock order from Chas. F. Luehrmann Hardwood Lumber Company.”
On August 14,1917, appellant advanced $500, and on September 9, 1917, made an additional advance of $250, and on each occasion took a bill of sale for certain piles of lumber therein described. Appellees contended that these bills of sales were mere mortgages intended to secure the advances made; but the court found that they jWere in fact bills of sale, and appellees have prosecuted Vno appeal from that finding.
A controversy arose between the parties, and appellant brought suit in replevin for the lumber covered by the bills of sale, and by an amended complaint prayed judgment for damages for breach of the contract to deliver lumber. An answer was filed to the original complaint, in which ownership of the lumber replevied was denied; and while no answer appears to have been filed to the amended complaint, its allegations were treated as being in issue.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit