Supreme Court of Kansas April 10, 1920, No. 22,574 (Powell v. Valentine)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-04-1920

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Dawson, J.:

• This action was for an injunction to restrain unfair trade practices.

The plaintiffs, who for some years past had respectively conducted morning and evening newspapers in Coffeyville, the “Sun” and the “Journal,” formed a partnership in January, 1919, consolidated their newspapers, suspended the publication of the “Sun,” and thereafter continued to serve the readers of both papers by the publication of the “Journal.” The plaintiff Platz, who had been the individual owner of the “Sun” before. the merger, continued to maintain a business office for the “Sun,” carried a bank account under its name, received and issued checks in the name of the “Sun,” and attended to the business of the suspended publication.

On February 2, 1919, the defendant, who theretofore had been publishing a paper in Coffeyville for free distribution, called the “Earth,” commenced the publication of a new morning paper in Coffeyville, called the “Sun.” The plaintiffs at once protested against the use of the name “Sun,” and as their protest was disregarded, this action was begun. A restraining order was issued, and upon a full hearing some days later the district court granted a temporary injunction,

“That the defendant, A. J. Valentine, be and he hereby is restrained and enjoined from employing in his business conducted at Coffeyville, Kansas, the name of ‘The Sun,’ or ‘The Morning Sun,’ or any name employing the word ‘Sun,’ and these things he is restrained and enjoined from doing, either directly or indirectly.”

Defendant appeals, urging that the demurrer to plaintiffs’ evidence should have been sustained. The plaintiffs’ evidence tended to support the allegations of their petition. It is meas*647urably true that the full name of the earlier paper was “The Coffeyville, Kan.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.