Michigan Supreme Court April 10, 1920, Docket No. 45 (Ward v. De Young)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-04-1920
Sharpe, J.
On September 18, 1918, plaintiff was riding a bicycle along the south side of Fulton street, in the city of Grand Rapids.' Proceeding easterly, he came to the intersection of that street with Diamond avenue. When near the curb across the intersection, he collided with a truck belonging to defendant and driven by an employee named Martin De Young. The truck had been stopped on the north side of Fulton street, and about 100 feet east from the intersection. .When started by the driver, it proceeded somewhat diagonally across Fulton street to the point where the collision occurred. The truck struck the rear wheel of plaintiff’s machine, causing him to be thrown violently to the pavement and somewhat seriously injured.
The specific allegations of negligence of the defendant claimed by plaintiff and submitted by the trial court to the jury were:
“that defendant did not continue west'from in front of the store where his truck was standing beyond the *69center of Diamond avenue before turning to the south; that in turning to the south and passing diagonally across Fulton street, as the driver of defendant’s automobile did, that he was violating all rules of the road, both the statute of this State.and the ordinance of this city, and in violation of the common law rules that he should so use his automobile as not to injure the life or limb of any person; that in doing that, that the defendant was not in the exercise of due care and caution.”
The plaintiff had verdict and judgment for $2,000, and the defendant' brings error. There are many assignments, but they may be fairly grouped in the order in which we now consider them.
1. Negligence of the defendant. On direct-examination, the driver of the truck testified:
“When I started, I went on a kind of diagonal course south on Diamond. I should judge I had gone about 75 feet before I crossed the center of Fulton street, something like that. No, about 25 or 50 feet, something like that.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit