Michigan Supreme Court July 20, 1920, Docket No. 60 (Brusseau v. Brusseau)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-07-1920

Moore, J.

This is a divorce case. The bill was filed by the husband charging extreme cruelty and desertion. The plaintiff is about 70 years of age, and his wife is about 6 years younger. The defendant filed an answer to the bill of complaint denying the allegations in the bill, but asked for no affirmative relief. The evidence in the case is in a large measure the testimony of the parties plaintiff and defendant, and is contradictory and conflicting respecting nearly all of the facts relative to the deportment and conduct of one to the other. There are supporting witnesses on both sides of the controversy. The hearing was in open court. The circuit judge rendered a decree on both grounds of extreme cruelty and desertion and divided between the parties a fund which with the accumulated interest amounts to about $1,000 on deposit with the Huron & Erie Mortgage Corporation, of London, Ontario, giving to the wife two-thirds thereof, and the husband one-third. This is about all of the means possessed by the parties. The wife has appealed from this decree.

If the testimony of the plaintiff is true he has amply sustained the averments of his bill. If the testimony of the defendant is true he has failed to> do so. The parties quarreled frequently. The wife left home twice and each time came back. In 1907 she left home for good, claiming she was justified in doing so because of the cruelty of her husband to herself and to her children.

We quote a few sentences from her testimony:

“Q. Your husband spoke to you several times that *528you should draw that money out and divide it between you?

“A. He never said that to me.

“Q. That word was brought to you?

“A. Yes, sir, he wanted to have the money and be divorced: I said, I am a Catholic, I don't want any divorce. * * * After we separated my husband wanted me to come back home, but I would not.

“Q. But, anyway, it was your own doings that you would not go back?

“A. My own mind. * * *

“Q.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.