Supreme Court of Minnesota October 29, 1920, No. 21,887 (Nygard v. Minneapolis Street Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-10-1920

Holt, J.

Defendant’s motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict being denied, it appeals from the judgment.

Plaintiff sued to recover damages for injuries received in an accident while carried as a passenger in defendant’s street car. On the trial liability was conceded. The defense was a release. To this defense plaintiff replied that the release was executed under a mutual mistake in respect to the injuries received. The only question presented by the appeal is whether, as a proposition of law, there is my evidence warranting the jury in finding such to be the fact.

As plaintiff was standing in the doorway of the street car, preparatory to leaving, the car was run violently against a cement post guarding the end of the track, throwing plaintiff down, and severely bruising her right arm, shoulder and hip. She was on her way to work, but the injuries compelled her to return home. As she was dependent upon her own efforts for the support of herself and two children, it was necessary for her to try to work as soon as possible. Her attempts were not successful, and, at the end of 10 days, she, with a friend; came to defendant’s claim department, described how and where-she had been injured, and stated that she ought to be compensated. From what she then knew, of her injuries, and as disclosed to defendant’s claim agent, it was estimated that in four weeks recovery would be complete. The loss of earnings for that period was figured at about $50 by the parties. This sum *111was paid her, and she executed the release in question. No doubt, she would have recovered within the time estimated, had there been no other injuries than those then known to the parties. Instead of improving, she grew worse and had to seek medical treatment. It was then ascertained that her affliction was hysterical paralysis, a very serious disease.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.