Mississippi Supreme Court March 15, 1920, No. 21036 (Banfill v. Byrd)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1920

Ethridge, J.,

delivered the opinion, of the court.

The appellant sued the appellees for damages for an unlawful search of her1 hotel. The appiellee Byrd was chief of police of Gulport, and the Maryland Casualty Company was surety on his official bond. On the 31st day of December Byrd procured a search warrant from the police court clerk, authorizing him to search the hotel known as the Union Hotel in ¡Gulfport, Miss., and, accompanied by a policeman and a body. of marines, proceeded to search the Union Hotel for intoxicating liquors. They failed to find the intoxicating liquors, and so »retuimej¡l on the warrant. Theireatftejr tM$ suit 'was brought and the general issue pleaded by the defendants, after having first demurred to the declaration and having such demurrers overruled by the court.

On the trial the plaintiff testified that the officer came to the hotel accompanied by a policeman and several marines, and handed her a copy of a search warrant, saying, “Here is a warrant to search this house,” and she said, “Search it.” She was asked on her examination as a witness, “Was there any particular room you objected to their searching’?” and answered:

“No, sir; they did not complete the search. I was willing for them to go to every part. Q. Didn’t you have a young man that remained there permanently, a Greek? A. Yes, sir. Q>. Did they search his room? A. Yes, sir. He is not there at present. He is recuperating at St. Charles, La. Q. Did you object to them going to his room? A. I asked them to come out of that room, but they paid no attention and they ransacked the closet and tore up> his suit clothes and scattered everything: all over the floor.”

She was asked on direct examination: “Were you humiliated by the search?’ A. Very naturally I was; that is why I am here to-day. ”

*295She was then asked: “Did it hurt the reputation of your hotel 1 A. It certainly didn’t help it any; naturally anything like that affects a public place.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.