Mississippi Supreme Court October 15, 1920, No. 21237 (Allen & Co. v. Monroe County Hay Exchange)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1920

William H. Cooic, J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

The Monroe County Hay Exchange sued Allen & Co. in ah action of attachment on open account for the proceeds of three cars of hay collected and retained by it. The defendant, Allen & Co., denied the indebtedness and filed a set off and counterclaim for damages accruing to it by reason of the failure and refusal of the plaintiff to ship other cars of hay alleged to have been purchased from plaintiff and resold, thereby making it necessary for the defendant to go into the market and buy hay at greatly increased prices. Upon the trial of the debt issue there was a verdict and judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.'

*507. The Monroe County Hay Exchange is a corporation engaged in buying and selling hay, and appellant, Allen & Co., composed alone of C. A. Allen, was engaged in the brokerage business in the city of Birmingham,, Ala. During the year 1916 the Hay Exchange sold to or through Allen numerous carloads of hay, which were either consigned to him or shipped to buyers designated by him, and he was paid a commission for each car sold.

This controversy grows out of certain contracts alleged to have been made by the telegraphic correspondence hereinafter set out: On the .morning of June 22, 1916, Allen & Company wired the Hay Exchange as follows:

“Western Union Telegram.

“6-22-16.

“To Monroe County Hay Exchange, Prairie, Mississippi. Birmingham Grain offers seventeen dollars five cars choice alfalfa, shipment within ten days, wire answer.

“Allen & Company.”

This message was at once answered by the Hay Exchange as follows:

“Prairie, Miss. 12-23 P. M. June 22, 1916.

“Allen & Company, Birmingham, Ala. Will fill your order fon five cars hay.

“Mo,nroe. County Hay Exchange — 12—53PM.”

On the same day, after he had wired the order for five cars for the Birmingham Grain Company, appellant sent appellee the following telegram:

“Birmingham, Ala. 6 — 22—16.

“To Monroe County Hay Exchange, Prairie, Miss.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.