Montana Supreme Court October 27, 1920, No. 4,189 (Zalac v. Barich)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-1920

MR. JUSTICE COOPER

delivered the opinion of the court.

The complaint alleges that between the nineteenth day of February, 1910, and the 19th of June, 1916, at the special instance and request of defendants, the plaintiff rendered services to them, as cook, housekeeper and servant girl, of the reasonable value of $25 per month, for which they agreed to pay a reasonable wage, and that only $334 of the $1,566 alleged to be due plaintiff has ever been paid.

The answer consists of a general denial, supplemented by affirmative allegations to the effect that, in consideration for *430the services rendered by plaintiff, defendants agreed to and did furnish plaintiff with a home, and treated her and cared for her as their own child; that the plaintiff was informed and understood that, if she desired to work for wages elsewhere, she was at liberty to do so, because defendants could not afford to pay her any wages or salary, but that plaintiff preferred to remain with defendants and enjoy the benefits of the home so provided, and that, in addition to the home, “defendants expended a sum of money in so providing a home, rendered entertainment and education for said plaintiff, vastly in excess of the sum demanded-by plaintiff in her complaint.” Upon these issues a trial was had, resulting in a verdict for plaintiff in the sum of $750. -This appeal is from the judgment and an order denying defendants a new trial.

Eefusal of the trial court to grant defendants a new.trial is the principal ground urged upon this appeal, the contention of appellants being that the proof offered by the plaintiff failed to establish the date upon which the agreement was made, and that, for that reason, the verdict is based upon guesswork, conjecture and speculation, and ought not to be permitted to stand.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.