Supreme Court of New Jersey March 1, 1920 (Howell v. Lehigh Valley Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-1920

The opinion of the court was. delivered by

Kalisch, J.

This case in its salient features is like Fidelity and Plate Glass Insurance Company against this defendant, reported in 92 N. J. L. 467.

The facts of that case, which gave rise to the questions concerning the alleged negligence of the defendant, are practically the same here, and, therefore, need not be reiterated. There the main questions were whether the facts which appeared from the plaintiff’s proof tended to establish negligence *214of the defendant, and whether the correct legal principles governing those facts were property stated by the court to the jury for its guidance, both of which questions we answered in the affirmative.

Wherein the present ease differs from the one cited is in that, here, tlie defendant for the first time introduced testimony, in its behalf, tending to- controvert the- plaintiff’s prima, facie case, but it is obvious from an examination of this new testimony that it does not in legal effect constitute a complete bar to the plaintiff’s right of recovery, and, at most, only raised issues of fact which were for the consideration and decision of a jury. Thus, as instances- illustrative of this comment, were the questions whether the fire and explosions were due to incendiarism or to spontaneous combustion, or whether tlie fire and explosion had its origin in a schooner loaded with explosive substances, which, vessel, it was alleged was unlawfully moored to- tlie- pier of the defendant without its knowledge or consent,' or whether the explosion on the schooner preceded the explosion on land.

Counsel of appellant argues that the court below erred to the prejudice of the defendant in stating to the jury that the measure of duty which the' defendant was legally bound to exercise in the care- of these highly dangerous explosives was care commensurate with ‘the risk of danger.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.