Supreme Court of New Jersey March 1, 1920 (Isaac v. Ellis)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-03-1920
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Ackekson, J.
The plaintiff and defendant entered into a contract over the telephone for the-sale by plaintiff to defendant of five carloads of heavy melting steel, and thereafter on *250the same day each of the parties wrote the other a letter expressing the terms of the agreement as understood by the writer. Defendant wrote plaintiff as follows:. “As per conversation we had with you this date we confirm having purchased from you five cars of heavy melting steel suitable and acceptable on our order to Coatesville,- Pa., at $16.25 G-. T. F. O. B. ears C. R. R. tracks Jersey City, N. J. We have this day applied for a permit to cover movement of this material.” Plaintiff’s letter to defendant read: “Confirming my telephone call, I beg to confirm ¡sale to you of five (5) cars steel scrap at sixteen twenty-five (16.25) dollars per gross ton f. o. b. ears Jersey City, 0. R. R. of N. J. Please have permit issued for these cars at once, as material will be loaded Monday.” These letters crossed in the mail. The plaintiff endeavored several times, to malee delivery, but defendant each- time refused to have the steel shipped, claiming that it was unable, because of an embargo on shipments to Coatesville, to procure a permit therefor. Thereupon the plaintiff sold the steel elsewhere, resulting in a loss, brought suit against defendant and recovered judgment from which defendant appeals upon two grounds—first, “that said judgment was given for the plaintiff and against the defendant, whereas by the law of the land judgment ought to have been given for the defendant against the plaintiff,” and second, that the trial judge erroneously denied defendants motion for the direction of a verdict in its favor at the close of the whole case. Since there is no reason advanced why the judgment should have been.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit