Supreme Court of New Jersey June 14, 1920 (State v. Linker)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-06-1920

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Walker, Chancellor.

The defendants were ponvicted in the-Salem Quarter Sessions of the offence of keeping-a disorderly house and sued out a writ of error from the Supreme Court, where the judgment was affirmed; and that affirmance has been brought into this court by writ of error for review. In the Supreme Court the following opinion was filed:

“Per Curiam : The defendants were convicted of keeping a disorderly house. The indictment was in the common law form, charging that the defendants kept the house for their own proffit and gain, and that certain persons, men and women of evil name and fame, collected there drinking, tippling, fighting, gambling, &c.

“It is urged that the verdict should have been not, guilty. This is a matter which cannot be considered on error, if there was any evidence to justify the submission of the case to the wry-

*413“We think there was. ample evidence of drunkenness and disorder^ conduct.

“It is. argued that it was- error for the court to permit proof of the sale of hard cider and wine by the defendants to frequenters of the house, because there was no charge in the indictment that liquors, were sold contrary to law. Our decisions, however, hold to the contrary. See State v. Rairorf, 64 N. J. L. 412; State v. Derby, 60 Id. 258.

“It is also urged that there was error in the charge to the jury by reason of comments made by the court upon the testimony, particularly with relation to saies of hard cider and red wine. There was no misreeital of the evidence by the court, and reasonable comment on the evidence was within the province of the court.

- “It is contended that the court refused to charge the jury certain requests which were submitted, which substantially were that the jury could not convict the defendants of keeping a disorderly house upon the testimony as to the alleged sale of intoxicants, and that, therefore, such testimony should be disregarded by the jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.