Wisconsin Supreme Court June 23, 1920 (State ex rel. Milwaukee Electric Railway & Light Co. v. Braman)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-06-1920

RosenberRY, J.

In its effort to comply with the orders of the railroad commission requiring it to make the imT provements described in the statement of facts, the relator is met by the refusal of the defendant to permit the work to be done.

It is the contention of the defendant that the relator has no franchise for the construction of turnouts, sidetracks, connections, or cross-overs on Twenty-second avenue. This contention is based upon the following facts: The material part of the ordinance granting the franchise under which the relator claims is sec. 4 of the ordinance of January 2, 1900, which contains the following provision:

“Provided further, that in case of the extension of the city limits in the future, then said railway company is hereby authorized and obligated to make extension of any of its lines now or hereafter reaching the city limits as they now exist to the said city limits when so extended, . . . and when any such extension shall be made, all and singular the provisions of this ordinance relating to the operation thereof shall apply the same as though the provisions of this ordinance were made a part of the ordinance requiring such extension.”

It is the contention of the defendant that under the provisions of this ordinance, when the relator extended its line beyond the old city limits, the right to construct “all neces*136sary and convenient tracks, turnouts, sidetracks, connections, cross-overs, and switches” was not included because of the fact that the word operation is used, and no word relating to the construction of the line is used in connection with it, and therefore only that part of the ordinance which relates to the operation of the line is applicable.

We think this is entirely too strict a construction to place upon the language of this ordinance, and that when under an ordinance adopted pursuant to the provisions of sec. 4 the relator was compelled to extend its lines in accordance with the provisions of sec.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.