Tennessee Supreme Court September 15, 1920 (Pearson v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-09-1920
Mr. L. D. Smith, Special Justice,
delivered tbe opinion of the Court.
*387Plaintiff in error, Green Pearson, was convicted of voluntary manslaughter, in the circuit court of Hawkins county, for the killing of one James Short, on Sunday, January 11, 1920.
Plaintiff in error assigns several grounds of error to the judgment of conviction.
The first assignment is upon the facts of the case, and to the effect that the evidence preponderates in favor of the innocence of the plaintiff in error.
There is practically no conflict in the evidence as to the facts leading up to the killing. The deceased, Short, and plaintiff in error were brothers-in law; Short having married Pearson’s sister. They lived within about one hundred and fifty yards of each other on adjoining land. Bad feeling had existed between the two families for a number of years. The deceased was a fussy and quarrelsome man, and got along badly .with his neighbors. He had shown by threats and otherwise that he entertained very hostile feelings toward the plaintiff in error. It seems that there had been some controversy between the deceased and plaintiff in error with respect to a water course or ditch. With this ditch open the water would flow into the plaintiff in error’s premises, and he insistéd upon its being stopped up and filled, whereas the deceased insisted upon its being open.
On Sunday morning before the tragedy, plaintiff in error had left his home, and while he was gone, his daughter, about ten years of age, went down into the field, and was throwing out the rocks from this ditch which some of the family of the deceased had placed therein. At *388that time the deceased was sitting near his home, and in view of the Pearson home, on a pile of lumber.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit