Delaware Court of Oyer and Terminer May 13, 1920, Indictment No. 51 (State v. McIvor)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-05-1920

Pennewill, C. J.

(charging the jury). The defendant, John J. McIvor, is charged in this case with the crime of manslaughter. It is alleged in the indictment that on the 25th day of March of the present year, the defendant was running an automobile on the Philadelphia Pike in an unlawful m'anner; and while so doing, at a point on said pike north of Myrtle avenue, the automobile struck one Raymond B. Kelly and so injured him that he died a few days thereafter, as a result of his injuries. .

The defendant is charged with driving his automobile unlaw*126fully at the time of the accident: (1) Because he ran at a greater rate of speed than that allowed by the statute. (2) Because he was running on the wrong side of the road at and just before the accident. (3) Because he was driving his automobile at an unreasonable rate of speed without having regard to the traffic and so as to endanger the safety of any person or injure the property of any person on the highway.

The defendant denies that he was driving his automobile at the time of the accident at an unlawful rate-of speed or in an unlawful manner or so as to endanger the property or lives of others on the highway, and claims that the accident occurred because the deceased so suddenly appeared between the automobile and a large truck that was passing at the time that the defendant could not avoid hitting him although he applied his brakes and did all he could to stop his car in time. His defense, therefore, is that the accident occurred through no fault of his but entirely by misadventure.

The indictment being for manslaughter, it is necessary for us to define as clearly as we can what constitutes that crime.

Manslaughter is termed homicide, and is so called because it is the killing of a human being; but it is not malicious homicide, and is therefore unlike murder, which contains malice. It is the unlawful killing of another, without malice, express or implied, and is either voluntary or involuntary.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.