Court of Common Pleas of Ohio, Hamilton County July 15, 1920 (Brown v. Rawson)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-07-1920

Darby, J.

The plaintiff alleges that he is a tenant in common with the defendants of certain real property situate in Cincinnati at the southeast corner of Ninth and Race streets, and asks partition thereof, or if partition can not be had without manifest injury, that the same may be sold and the proceeds distributed according to the rights of the parties.

In a cross petition filed by Joseph Rawson, and which is adopted by the other parties in interest, it is alleged that the premises referred to are subject to a perpetual lease made by the ancestor of the parties.

The cause came on for hearing upon the petition, and objection was made to a decree in partition for the reason that the property, being subject to a perpetual lease, partition thereof could not be compelled. Subsequently, a motion was made' by the defendant, Joseph Rawson, to dismiss the action for the reason that the court is without jurisdiction over the subject matter thereof. By this motion the same question is raised as was raised upon the hearing of the cause, namely, that existence of the perpetual lease upon the property prevents its partition. It should be noted in passing that the cross-petition of Joseph Rawson and the other defendants asked for partition úpon the said cross-petition.

The question for determination is this: May one tenant in common of real property, subject to a perpetual lease, compel partition of said property during the life of the lease?

General Code, 12026 provides:

“Tenants in common, and coparceners of any estate in lands, tenements or hereditaments within the state, may be compelled to make or suffer partition thereof in the manner hereinafter prescribed.”

That the parties to this action are tenants in common of an estate in lands goes without saying. That the parties to this *107action are bound by the lease of their ancestor is equally true.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.