Supreme Court of Puerto Rico February 16, 1920, No. 457 (Torres v. Registrar of Guayama)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-02-1920

Mr. Justice del Toro

delivered the opinion of the court.

Florencio Torres and Dámaso Caraballo brought a posses-*53sory title proceeding in the District Court of G-nayama to establish their possession as owners of a rural property situated in Patillas. The proceeding was prosecuted according to the formalities prescribed by the Mortgage Law and the court finally held that the possession had been proved and directed that the title be recorded in the district registry. The original record was presented in the registry and the registrar refused to record it because the proceeding was brought in the district court of this city instead of in the Municipal Court of Patillas, the court having jurisdiction in this case, and because witnesses Luis Texidor and' Antero Aponte, who testified at the hearing, are not residents of Patillas and the said Antero Aponte is not a property owner of that municipality.”’

1. The registrar’s first ground of refusal to record the title is without merit. According to article 390 of the Mortgage Law, possessory title proceedings are brought, as a general rule, in the court of first instance, now the district court, of the district in which the property is situated, and “if the property should be situated in a town or district in which there is no judge of first instance, the proceedings may be had before the municipal judge.” Therefore it is optional with the parties in a case like this to bring the proceedings in the district court or in the municipal court. The two courts have concurrent jurisdiction. See G-alindo’s opinion to that effect at page 613, volume 4, of the fourth edition of his Legislación Hipotecaria.

2. The second ground is well founded. The statue provides that “in the proceedings two or more witnesses shall be heard, who shall be residents and landowners of the town • or municipal district in which the property may be situated.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.