Supreme Court of Puerto Rico June 24, 1920, No. 276 (Santini v. López Acosta)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-06-1920

Mr. Justice del Toro

delivered the opinion of the court.

This is a petition for a writ of certiorari. The petitioners are the plaintiffs in an action brought against Ra-món San Miguel and others in the District Court' of Grua-yama for the nullity of a contract, the acknowledgment of ownership and for damages. In 1889 Ramón Santini, the *617father of the petitioners, purchased a certain rural property in Aibonito while married to Joaquina Rodríguez, the mother of the petitioners. The mother died. The father married again and in 1893, without the intervention of the children, sold the said property to defendant San Miguel, who later sold a part of the property, but is still in possession of the remainder.

After being* summoned the defendant moved that the heirs of his grantor be summoned as warrantors. At the same time he filed a demurrer to the complaint, alleging that it was without prejudice to the motion. The summons in warranty was ordered but not executed. The demurrer was heard by the court and decided in favor of the defendant. The plaintiffs amended their complaint. The defendant again demurred and answered. Later he moved for a judgment on the pleadings and his motion was finally sustained. The plaintiffs appealed and on July 31, 1919, this court reversed the judgment appealed from and remanded the case for further proceedings. Santini et al. v. Díaz San Miguel et al., 27 P. R. R. 746.

In these circumstances and the case being once more before the district court, the defendant again moved that the heirs of his grantor be summoned as warrantors. The motion was sustained and the plaintiffs moved for a reconsideration of the court’s ruling on the following grounds:

A. Because defendant Ramón Díaz San Miguel has no right in this case to such a summons in warranty, inasmuch as the sale involved was not made to him by the mother of the plaintiffs, but by their father in the name of a conjugal partnership which did not exist.

B.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.