District Court, S.D. New York January 15, 1920, No. 16-36 (American Surety Co. of New York v. American Mills Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1920

ROSE, District Judge.

[1] The plaintiff seeks the cancellation of ^a bond given to the defendant by the Hartenfeld Bag Company as principal, and itself as surety, and an injunction against suits thereon. The three corporations concerned are of New York, Georgia, and Illinois, respectively, and will be herein severally called the “surety,” the “Mills,” and the “Bag Company.”

For seven years, ending in 1918, the former had bought secondhand bags from the latter, sometimes to the amount of $100,000 annually. Frequently, if not usually, payment had preceded delivery. In August, 1918, the Bag Company was behind in its shipments, and some of the bags which it had furnished had been undergrade. At that time the Bag Company was indebted to the Mills in the amount of about $12,000., Nevertheless, when near the end of August the Mills bought more bags, the Bag Company persuaded it to give, for their purchase price, its notes, aggregating something over $9,000. The Bag Company had been in the habit of selling its accounts to the Commercial Credit Company of Baltimore. Notwithstanding that the notes of the Mills had fully paid for the last purchases, the Bag Company sold its bill for them to the Credit Company, and a few days later discounted the promissory notes of the Mills with a Chicago banker. In this way it obtained double payment for bags which it had certainly never shipped, and which it had probably at that time not even bought.

On the 24th of September, through a telegram from the Credit Company telling the Mills that it had bought the Bag Company’s account against it, and stating that a formal notice to that effect had been mailed, the Mills got wind of at least part of what had happened. In due course, the letter of the Credit Company came to hand. It asked to be promptly informed if the Mills claimed any payment, credits, notes, etc., against the account.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.