Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit January 6, 1920, No. 2715 (De Vry Corp. v. Acme Motion Picture Projector Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-01-1920

BAKER, Circuit Judge.

This is an appeal from a decree dismissing for want of equity the appellant’s bill for alleged infringement of patent No.- 929,678, issued on August 3, 1909,. to Dockwood for improvements in apparatus for exhibiting moving pictures. The decree followed a ruling sustaining appellee’s motion to dismiss, which was in the nature of a general demurrer.

Claims 14, 15, and 16 were the only ones counted on in the bill. As these claims are all of the same effect so far as determining the correctness of the ruling on demurrer is concerned, only one of them is subjoined.

“16. In an apparatus for exhibiting moving pictures, the combination with a cabinet having a picture film therein, of a light and a light condenser therein, an inclosing casing for said, lamp and condenser, and a rotary fan for withdrawing the heated air from ■ said casing and discharging it without said cabinet.”

In his specification the applicant acknowledged that the motion picture cabinet, with its necessary proj ecting means, was old in the art. He noted that the pictures are printed on a highly inflammable film of celluloid. “To guard against the possibility of igniting the inflammable film,” he said, “I have provided a ventilating apparatus by means of which the air heated by the lamp and in the projector is withdrawn and discharged from the cabinet. As shown, 'this comprises a rotary fan driven by the motor and which is connected to the casing surrounding the lamp and containing the light condenser; and the fan is *971connected with a conduit for discharging the hot air out of the cabinet. Thus tire temperature within the chamber is prevented from rising to the danger point.”

In Lange v. McGuin, 177 Fed. 219, 101 C. C. A. 389, we spoke of the demurrer in equity pleading in this way:

“It is not tire province oí a demurrer to speak of matters beyond tbe bill.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.