Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit June 3, 1920, No. 2550 (Pittsburgh Coal Co. v. Boyd)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-06-1920
HAIGHT, Circuit Judge.
Boyd, the appellee, claiming that a houseboat which belonged to him had been wrecked through the negligence of those in charge of the steamboat Active, which was owned by the Pittsburgh Coal Company, the appellant, filed a libel in the court below against the steamboat to recover the damages which he thus sustained, and was awarded the decree from which this appeal is taken.
It appears that some months prior to February, 1917, Boyd, with the consent of the appellant, but without any compensation to the latter, had moored his houseboat at a wharf or landing of the appellant on the Monongahela river, at Monongahela City, Pa. In the latter part of February, due to some cause which the evidence does not disclose, but presumably through no fault attributable to the appellant, the houseboat sank. It remained in that condition until March 9th, when the river had risen to a flood stage, and the houseboat had drifted partially under or very close to one or more of the boaLs of the appellant, which were moored there. Thereupon one of appellant’s superintendente, becoming apprehensive that the houseboat would endanger the safety of some of the .appellant’s fleet, ordered those in charge of the Active to move the houseboat. As all of the latter, except the upper part of tlie cabin, was then submerged, a hole was cut in the roof of the cabin, and a line, which was attached to the capstan of the steamboat and passed through a snatchblock, fastened to the shore abutment, was made fast to one of the roof timbers. The engine of the Active was then started, and the houseboat was pulled a short distance up the river and sidewise towards the shore, where it was made fast with a line running from one of the roof timbers of the cabin, through the hole in the roof, to a post on shore, and apparently, although the evidence seems to be conflicting on this point, by a line from one of the hulls of the boat to the abutment.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit