Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit October 4, 1920, No. 3467 (Muir v. Morris)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-10-1920

ROSS, Circuit Judge.

The appellant sought by this suit a decree declaring that in and prior to the month of June, 1905, the appellees held the legal title to 1,000 shares of the capital stock of the Oregon Water Power & Railway Company, in trust for the appellant’s testate, William T. Muir, and continued to hold the stock for the latter and his successors in interest until about April 27, 1906, when they sold all of the stock of the power and railway company, including the 1,000 shares so held in trust by them, at the price of $65 a share, and that after such sale, the appellees held the sum of $65,000 for Muir until his death on the 4th day of November, 1911, and that ever sin'ce the date last mentioned the appellees have held and now hold the said money in trust for the appellant herein as representative of said William T. Muir, deceased, for which amount, with interest and costs of suit, the appellant prayed judgment.

The defendants to the suit interposed various defenses, among which was one setting up in bar an action brought by Muir June 24, 1911, in a state court of Oregon, in which action the present appellant was substituted as executrix of the estate of the deceased, Muir, which action resulted in a judgment of the trial court granting a motion made by the defendants thereto (who are the present appellees) for a nonsuit and dismissing the action, which judgment was subsequently affirmed hy the Supreme Court of the state on appeal thereto. Muir v. Morris, 80 Or. 378, 154 Pac. 117, 157 Pac. 785. Thereafter a petition for a rehearing of the case was presented to the court in banc *98on consideration of which petition the court states (80 Or. at page 393, 157 Pac. 785) that—

“In response to an urgent petition for a rehearing the entire record has again been examined.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.