Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit July 3, 1920, No. 206 (Schoonmaker Conners Co. v. Lambert Transp. Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-07-1920
ROGERS, Circuit Judge
(after stating the facts as above). [1] It appears, and indeed is conceded, that when the Kaaterskill was char*104tered to the Lambert Transportation Company, respondent herein, 'she was in good condition, and that when the boat was returned she was in bad condition. It was therefore incumbent upon the aforesaid respondent to show: (1) How the damage occurred; and (2) that it was not caused through its negligence, or through the negligence of any one to whom the respondent had intrusted the boat. White v. Upper Hudson Stone Co., 248 Fed. 893, 160 C. C. A. 651; Terry & Trench v. Merritt & Chapman Derrick & Wrecking Co., 168 Fed. 533, 93 C. C. A. 613.
3. That the libelant is entitled to a decree is admitted by the Lambert Transportation Company, Incorporated, the respondent. The real matter in issue, therefore, is as to the liability of the Acme Steamship Corporation, which is impleaded. It is admitted that, when the scow was returned to the libelant, she was not only not in the same condition she was in when she was taken over, but that she was indeed in a very bad condition. As the charter party contained a covenant wherein it was agreed that the scow was to be returned in like condition as on delivery, reasonable wear and tear excepted, the liability of the respondent is of course beyond any question.
[2] The difficulty in the case arises over the relation of the Acme Steamship Corporation to the matter, and is due to the fact that, after the respondent took over the scow under its chartlr with the libelant, it in turn subchartered her to the Acme Steamship Corporation, and in doing so failed through carelessness to exact of the latter a covenant for the return of the boat in the same condition as she was in on delivery, reasonable wear and tear excepted.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit