District Court, S.D. New York August 7, 1920 (Kalamazoo Loose Leaf Binder Co. v. Wilson Jones Loose Leaf Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-08-1920
LEARNED HAND, District Judge.
I think that these patents can best be considered upon the assumption that they concern three separate inventions: First, the sheet and binder, with fixed and removable posts and open slots and closed holes; second, the W rack to be used *716with such a binder; third, the adjustability of such a rack to the horizontal and the rack with one fixed horizontal side.
Of these the first invention is described in the Wigginton patents, Nos. 1,174,458 and 1,222,705, relating to “temporary binder or loose sheet holder,” both being originally one application, filed March 19, 1915. In order to an understanding of the patent, there should be some statement of the situation in the art at the time when it appeared. The loose leaf ledger long antedated any of these inventions and was the discovery at the base of them all. The advent of the Burroughs posting machine created the need for modifications in the general style of such ledgers. If the bookkeeper was delayed in removing or replacing a sheet on which additions were to be made, there would be no advantage in using a posting machine. The. hand bookkeeper in any event had the start on him, because, having found his place, he could at once begin to make his entries. It therefore became of consequence to have a quick method of talcing out the sheets and putting them back.
In 1911 or 1912, when the machine began first to appear, it was used upon loose bodies of sheets, which were kept in a box or simply held together by an elastic band until they were filled and ready for permanent filing. This had disadvantages, real or fancied, and it therefore became desirable to have a temporary binder, in which they could be kept, and from and into which they could be easily taken out or put.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit