California Court of Appeal November 16, 1921, Civ. No. 3933. (Cypress Lawn Cemetery Ass'n v. Lievre)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1921

WASTE, P. J.

The plaintiff brought this action to enjoin the defendants from maintaining along the state highway, in front of and adjacent to its cemetery, in San Mateo County, portable stands for the sale of flowers and floral

*229

decorations, and from obstructing the entrances to the cemetery grounds. The lower court determined that the maintenance of these stands and the selling of flowers therefrom created a nuisance by interrupting traffic and interfering with plaintiff’s ingress and egress, and with the passage of its patrons to and from the highway and in and out of the cemetery. It granted a perpetual injunction, from which judgment the defendants appeal.

The respondent owns land on both sides of the Mission road, a public highway in San Mateo County, for a distance of some two thousand five hundred feet. Part of it is occupied as a cemetery, which extends far back on both sides of the road. On a portion of the property adjacent to the highway, and about one hundred feet from it, respondent erected a building containing its business offices and a flower-store, which was conducted in the premises. It has constructed and maintained an entrance in front • of this building from the highway, which connects with and joins the main entrance to the cemetery, which, in turn, is the main and only public entrance to the cemetery on both sides of the roadway.

Until and prior to about six months before the filing of this action the appellant Marie Lievre had for a period of seventeen years maintained a movable flower-stand on the side of the highway at a point directly in front of the present location of the recently erected office building. When that structure was completed Mrs. Lievre was ordered away from that point. She thereupon moved her stand to a point on the roadway about nine feet away from the northerly entrance to that structure, where she continued .to maintain her stand for the sale of flowers.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.