Court of Appeals of Texas January 25, 1921, No. 2329. (Lancaster v. Morgan)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-01-1921

WILLSON, C. J.

(after stating the facts as above). The Director General of Railroads insists the judgment should have been in his favor, and therefore that the trial court erred when he refused to instruct the jury

to

find for him, because the testimony, he says, did not warrant a finding that he was guilty of negligence in leaving engine 794 unattended on long alley track; or, if it did warrant such a finding, it conclusively appeared, he further says, that the risk due to leaving said engine unattended was one the deceased assumed.

It is plain enough, we think, that the jury had a right to say from the testimony that the engine, with defects calculated to release, and which, if they were set, did release, brakes intended to hold it, was left with steam up' and unblocked on a down grade leading to the main line track, to which it moved, where trains were frequently passing and where it collided with the engine on which the deceased was at work, killing him; and it is further plain enough, we think, that the jury had a right to conclude that leaving the engine unattended under those circumstances was negligence. Railway Co. v. Lafferty, 57 Fed. 536, 6 C. C. A. 474; Mars v. Railway Co., 54 Hun, 625, 8 N. Y. Supp. 107.

The insistence that it appeared as a matter of law that the risk from leaving the engine unattended was one the deceased assumed is predicated on testimony set out in the statement above showing it to have been a custom known to the deceased, the Director General asserts, to leave engines unattended as 794 was left on the occasion of the accident. As we understand the testimony, it did not conclusively or otherwise appear that such a custom existed, nor, if it did, that deceased knew of it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.