Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit April 6, 1921, No. 5710 (Stoffregen v. Moore)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-04-1921
CARLAND, Circuit Judge.
The parties to this litigation will be referred to as they were in the trial court. The plaintiff commenced action at law against the defendant to recover certain income taxes paid under protest, After issue joined a jury was duly waived and the action tried to the court. The court, after hearing the evidence, found the issues generally for the defendant, and entered judgment accordingly. The plaintiff brought the case here on writ of error.
Counsel for plaintiff assigns three errors. The first two assignments of error are to the effect that the court erred in making certain assumptions of fact. The third assignment of error is to the effect that the court erred in rendering judgment for the defendant, for the reason that under the law and the facts judgment ought to have been entered for the plaintiff. ,
[ 1] The assumptions of fact complained of in assignments of error 1 and 2 are found, if anywhere, in a memorandum opinion of the trial court incorporated for some reason in what is called a bill of exceptions. These two assignments of error present nothing for review: First, because they are based upon the opinion! of the court, which cannot be the basis of an assignment of error. The opinion may be wrong, and still the judgment be right. Second, we are by statute forbidden from reversing a judgment for error of fact on writ of error. Rev. St. § 1011; Comp. Stat. § 1672.
[2] None of the assignments present anything for this court to review, for the reason that they are not based upon any ruling of the trial court, and in addition assignment No. 3 is too indefinite to present anything for consideration here. U. S. v. A., T. & S. F. Ry. Co., 270 Fed. 1, decided January 12, 1921; Mercantile Trust Co. v. Wood et al., 60 Fed. 346, 8 C. C. A. 658; United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co. v. Board of Com’rs of Woodson County, Kan., 145 Fed. 144, 76 C. C. A. 114; Webb et al. v. Nat. Bank of Republic of Chicago, 146 Fed. 717, 718, 719, 77 C. C. A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit