Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 15, 1922 (Claim of Doherty v. David Lupton Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1922
Van Kirk, J.:
Claimant was working for the David Lupton Company, engaged in the business of constructing iron and placing plate glass windows. These windows were embedded or fixed in place with a black substance like cement. While taking this substance from the barrels it was scattered upon the floor, got upon the feet of the men, and in turn upon the rungs of the ladders being used. The claimant, while carrying water to the men, got this black substance upon his hands, and, in rubbing his face with his hands, during the heat of the day, the substance got in the eyes, which became inflamed. Claimant testifies that he never had trouble with his eyes before and never wore glasses. Since the injury he has not been able to do work, because he could not see.
At the first hearing the defendants objected to the award, first, on the ground of delayed notice; and second, on the ground that claimant did not sustain an accident in the course of his employment; that such eye trouble as he has was not due to any accident during his employment.
He stopped work about August 27, 1920. He got the paste in his eyes about August twenty-fourth or twenty-fifth. His claim is dated the 8th day of June, 1921. He reported his condition to the superintendent, Callahan, “ right afterwards, that day,” and Callahan told him to go to the first aid. Callahan testifies that he saw the claimant rubbing his eyes and that his eyes were all inflamed; the next day his eyes were worse; that he told the manager “ I don’t think much of it [the paste]; we have one man in the hospital now with it; the water-boy, in going up the ladder, got it on his hands and rubbed it in his eyes.” This evidence disposes of the first objection. The superintendent and the manager were informed of the claimant’s condition within two or three days after the accident. This was notice to the employer. The Industrial Board was justified in excusing failure to give the formal notice within the time.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit