New York Supreme Court April 15, 1922 (Russell v. Church)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1922
MacCrate, J.
Relying on cases similar to People v. Johnson, 237 Ill. 237; Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co. v. Chicago, 264 Ill. 24, and People v. Kellogg, 67 Hun, 546, and finding no case in this state directly criticizing or overruling the latter, wherein it was held that death before acceptance revokes an offer of dedication, it was held herein that the death of John Ackland revoked the offer of dedication made by him when he plotted and sold with reference to the plot. In People v. Johnson, supra, the reason for the decision is stated as follows: “The dedication is not complete until an acceptance, and as there must be two parties to a dedication, the offer to dedicate was revoked, by implication, by the death of Morrison.”
But in White v. Moore, 161 App. Div. 400, 403, it is said: “ While it is stated in various text books, and in the opinions in various decided cases, that an offer of dedication of land to public use does not become consummate until there has been an acceptance by the public, either formally or by user, or by some public act indicating acceptance, and that the offer may be revoked pending such acceptance, yet it is well and universally recognized that the revocation must be made by all the parties who have a legal interest in the lands subject to the offer of dedication to public use. Here the Du Bois grantees had acquired such legal interest. Without their consent the Du Bois grantors had no power to revoke, and their attempts to do so were of no avail.”
The case of Bridges v. Wyckoff, 67 N. Y. 130, cited in People v. Kellogg, supra, also holds a revocation of the dedication may ba made only by the dedicator and his grantees. The case of Wallace *475v. Townsend, 43 Ohio St. 537, also cited in People v. Kellogg, supra, deals with a subscription to stock and not with a dedication.
John Ackland, therefore, in his lifetime could not revoke the offer without the consent of the abutting grantees.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit