Supreme Court of Kansas June 10, 1922, No. 23,782 (Flynn v. Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-06-1922

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Mason, J.:

The widow of Patrick J. Flynn, who was a yardman in the employ of the Missouri Pacific Railroad Company, brought this action against the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen upon a beneficiary certificate issued by it to her husband. Payment was resisted, the defense being that he had been expelled from that organization several years before his death. Judgment was rendered in favor of the plaintiff on the ground that the expulsion proceedings were invalid. The defendant appeals.

1. An order was made by the lodge of which the plaintiff’s husband was a member (No. 281) expelling him from the brotherhood upon written charges and after a hearing, of the regularity of which no complaint is made except as hereinafter indicated. Under the laws of the order he might have appealed from the decision against him, first to the president and later if he desired to the grand lodge, but he took no appeal. The defendant urges that he was bound to exhaust his remedies within the organization before invoking the aid of the courts. This is the accepted rule with respect even to associations, membership in which carries property rights (Modern Woodmen v. Taylor, 67 Kan. 368, 71 Pac. 807) subject to this exception— if an order of expulsion is made by a tribunal of the society acting without jurisdiction, or in disregard of the accused member’s fundamental rights, as for instance where no opportunity for a hearing has been given him, relief at the hands of a court may be sought in the first instance. (Rueb v. Rehder, 24 N. M. 534, and cases there cited. See, also, 19 R. C. L. 1226, 1230, 1253, 1256; 5 C. J. 1359; 7 C. J. 1123; Supreme Lodge K. P. W. v. Wilson, 66 Fed. 785; Tucker v. Kirkpatrick, 106 Kan. 881, 189 Pac. 946; Id., 107 Kan. 541, 192 Pac. 834.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.