Supreme Court of New Jersey June 19, 1922 (State v. Currie)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-06-1922

Per Curiam.

The defendant was indicted in the Union Oyer and Terminer for publishing a criminal libel. He was convicted in the Quarter Sessions, to which the cause was referred for trial, and brought error to tire Supreme Court, where the judgment was affijrmed. He now brings error here. We are of opinion that the judgment of the Supreme Court should be affirmed and are satisfied with the treatment of the case in its per curiam, with the exception of the following observations. The opinion states:

“The first assignment urged in behalf of the ¡ilaintiff in error is that the opening words of the charge of the trial court were prejudicial to the defendant. The court made the following statement: Ut is the duty of the court to explain to you the law of the case, and it then becomes your duty to take the case and pass upon the questions of fact, including the ultimate fact of the guilt or innocence of the defendant. I say that you may then take the case and pass upon the facts. I ought to change that, because the constitution of this state in a libel case makes you the judge of the law as well as the facts. But first let me explain the general principles of law that surround this issue.’ ”

The opinion of the Supreme Court then proceeds:

“To hold that this is prejudicial error would be to hold that a judge who notices that he has made a mistake in his charge cannot correct that mistake by a subsequent statement. *581To hold as the counsel for the plaintiff in error contends would he to hold that under no circumstances can a judge correct a mistake in his charge that, lie notices he has made. The mere statement of this proposition demonstrates its unsoundncss.”

Mow, there does not appear in these excerpts from the charge that there is any mistake that was corrected. A careful reading of the charge discloses that the trial judge did not state that he had committed error and corrected it. This proposition is rather one of counsel’s conception.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.