Supreme Court of the United States November 12, 1923, 81 (Schwab v. Richardson)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-11-1923
Mr. Justice McKenna
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The case presents the validity of state taxation on the franchise of the Oceanic Steamship Company, a corporation of the State of California.
There is no dispute of facts. The case turns entirely upon the law applicable to them. The Company was organized to engage under California laws in the transportation of freight and passengers between San Francisco and the Hawaiian Islands and certain foreign countries, and did no intrastate business except the purchase of its fuel and supplies used in its transportation business.
: The Company made a written report to the State Board of Equalization as required by the law of the State. The report contained a concise statement and description of every franchise enjoyed by the Company, and other matters required of the Company by the law.
The Board, in pursuance of the law and the constitution of the State, determined the value of the franchise granted by the State to bé $120f000 and assessed and levied a tax
*90
thereon of one per cent, wmcn amounted to the sum of $1,200. It is contended that the assessment and levy were and are void under § 1 of Amendment XIV of the Constitution of the United States, because thereby the Board assessed and taxed the Company on property the situs of which was, for more than a year prior -to the assessment, and is, without the S.tate of California and beyond the jurisdiction of the State fon the purpose of taxation, and attempts to regulate and burden interstate and foreign commerce.
The specification of the means is expressed in the complain t, in addition to the situation of the Company’s property, as follows: The Company engaged in business outside of the State.. In assessing the franchise of. the Company the Board of Equalization did so in pursuance of a fixed rule .and general system which necessarily was discriminatory and inequitable.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit