Washington Supreme Court July 2, 1923, No. 17560 (Barto Co. v. Aylmore)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-07-1923
Mitchell, J.
This is an action by The Barto Company, a corporation, on two promissory notes, executed and delivered by the defendant to Barto & Sons Bank, a corporation, which notes were assigned and transferred to the plaintiff. One note is in the sum of $85 and interest, the other one $550 and interest. The statute of limitations was plead as a defense to the action upon each of the notes, and further it was answered that the $85 note had been given to cover an advance of expense money in connection with services to be *395rendered Barto & Sons Bank, and that as to the $550 note it was to be paid by services rendered and other expenses incurred by the defendant to and on behalf of Barto & Sons Bank, which services and expenses were rendered and incurred.
On the trial of the case, without a jury, there was judgment for the plaintiff on the $85 note, and against the plaintiff as to the larger note. The plaintiff has appealed from that part of the judgment against it.
The court found that, after the $550 note was given, the respondent performed legal services for and at the request of the payee, Barto & Sons Bank, of the reasonable value of the amount owing on the note and that, at the time of the employment, and rendition of the services, it was agreed that the value of such services should offset the note.
Upon an examination of the evidence, we are satisfied it does not support the finding. There is a dispute as to whether or not any agreement upon the subject was made; but, accepting the testimony of the respondent as true, which we do as did the trial court, it shows that, shortly after the note was given, one H. B. Barto, manager and an officer of Barto & Sons Bank, employed the respondent to render legal services in a case of H. B. Barto’s father-in-law before one of the United States land offices in Oregon, and from thence before the department in Washington, D. 0., with the understanding that his charges therefor .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit