Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 25, 1923 (Calascione v. Garrison)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-07-1923

Per Curiam:

The plaintiff was a passenger upon one of the subway trains operated by the defendant, and claims to have been injured by the negligent closing of the car door. The train upon which she *286was riding stopped at the station. The doors of the car were opened and all passengers evincing a desire to alight had the opportunity. The conductor, a young woman, then turned her gaze to the platform to see that all passengers desiring to enter the car did so before she closed the doors. After this had occurred, the plaintiff and her son arose and attempted to pass out of the door and while doing so the plaintiff was struck by the door in the process of closing. It is claimed that the defendant’s employee was negligent under these circumstances in closing the door.

The defendant was entitled to have the jury clearly instructed as to the burden of care cast upon it. “ It was bound to exercise reasonable and commensurate care in view of the dangers, to be apprehended.” (Fagan v. Atlantic Coast Line R. R. Co., 220 N. Y. 301, 306; McDonald v. Long Island R. R. Co., 116 id. 546.) The charge of the court did not clearly point out the degree of care the defendant was required to exercise. Plaintiff’s counsel made this request to charge: “ I ask your Honor to charge that the evidence in this case being that the conductorette in question did not look inside of the car again before closing the door in question, that your Honor charge the jury that that being the fact, the conductorette was guilty of negligence, as a matter of law. The Court: If such were the fact you mean? Plaintiff’s Counsel: That being the testimony, that not being denied. The Court: Well, it comes from an interested witness, you know. It is for the jury to determine the question of fact. Of course, if it is the fact that the door was closed without the guard looking to see whether anybody was entering or leaving, that would be negligence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.