Supreme Court of Georgia December 13, 1923, No. 3657 (Fulton Ice & Coal Co. v. Pece)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-12-1923

Beck, P. <7.

The petition for certiorari in this case contains exceptions to the holding of the Court of Appeals that the petition, except in the count which was held to be defective, set forth a cause of action against the plaintiff in certiorari, Fulton Ice & Coal Company. The applicant for certiorari criticises the holding in general terms, upon the ground that the effect of the decision is to lay down the broad doctrine that “the owner of a manufacturing plant is an absolute insurer of the safety of one lawfully on *106his premises, as against latent dangers which a reasonable inspection would have disclosed, although such owner was wholly without knowledge or notice of such defect, and although nothing had happened, and there was no fact or circumstance or report or other thing from which notice might be implied, or which would put a man of'even extraordinary prudence upon inquiry, and although such person was injured by an explosion of the very appliance he was employed to repair.” We are of the opinion that the Court of Appeals properly ruled that the petition stated a cause of action, and that it does not by its ruling or anything said in the opinion go to the extent of stating the doctrine which, in the criticism quoted, is ascribed to the opinion. A careful study of the opinion affords no grounds from which deductions could be made that are so broad and radical as are implied in the language of the criticism. No special part of the language in the decision is separated from the general holding and challenged upon the ground that it is too broad, inexact, or erroneous. The attack upon it is general. We agree with the Court of Appeals that the decision in the case of Dartmouth Spinning Co. v. Achord, 84 Ga. 14 (10 S. E. 449, 6 L. R. A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.