Court of Appeals of Kentucky April 27, 1923 (Maple v. Truax)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-04-1923

Opinion op the Court by

Judge Moorman

Reversing.

By a written contract of October 27, 1919, appellant sold a farm near Bloomfield, in Nelson county, to appellee for tbe stated consideration of “forty-three thousand, two hundred and fifty dollars,” $2,000.00 of which was paid in cash, the balance to be paid $16,000.00 on March 1, 1920, and $25,250.00 in equal installments of $6,312.50, due one, two, three and four years from March 1, 1920, with interest at the rate of six per cent, per annum until paid. On March 2, 1920, a deed" of conveyance was made for the consideration of “one dollar cash in hand and other valuable consideration.” It was recited in the deed, however, that for the balance of the consideration appellee had executed three promissory notes of $6,350.00 each, payable one, three and four years from that date, and had assumed the payment of a note of $5,200.00, to secure which there was- a lien.on the place. Appellee paid $2,000.00 when the contract was made and the $16,-000.00 when the deed was executed. On the latter date he executed his three.promissory notes for $6,350.00 each and assumed the payment of the $5,200.00 lien note. Thereafter a controversy arose between the parties as to the liability for the 1920 taxes, and on investigating the matter appellant discovered, as he claims, that the amount *803represented by the payments made and notes executed and assumed under the deed was $1,000.00 less than the true consideration as stated in the contract. He then instituted this suit, alleging that a mutual mistake was made in stating the consideration in the deed, and asking that the deed be reformed to show the real consideration, and, in the alternative, for judgment against appellee for $1,000.00, which he alleged was the difference between the real consideration and that represented by the payments made and notes executed. Issue was joined on this claim, proof taken, and judgment rendered dismissing the petition.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.