Utah Supreme Court August 21, 1923, No. 3934 (Sanders v. Milford Auto Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-08-1923

CHERRY, J.

This is an appeal by the plaintiff from a judgment rendered against him by default in favor of intervener.

On September 29, 1921, plaintiff commenced the action in claim and delivery against defendant to recover the possession of an automobile. By virtue of an affidavit, order, and undertaking, the sheriff took the automobile from the defendant, and in due time delivered it to the plaintiff. Thereafter, and on February 1, 1922, E. W. Clay, with the permission of the court, filed a complaint in intervention in the action, wherein he claimed the right of possession of the automobile and prayed for its recovery from the plaintiff with damages for detention. On March 13, 1922, the plaintiff voluntarily dismissed his complaint, and, on the same day, filed *112a motion to strike out portions of the complaint in intervention on tbe grounds of irrelevancy, etc. On June 29, 1922, and when the motion to strike was pending and undisposed of, upon the application of intervener’s attorney, the clerk entered the default of the plaintiff for not answering or demurring to the complaint in intervention within the time allowed by law, and, on the same day, in the absence of the plaintiff, intervener applied to the court for, and obtained, a judgment against the plaintiff for the recovery of the automobile, and for $250 damages, etc. On July 17, 1922, the plaintiff, without making an affidavit of merits or tendering a defense, filed a motion to set aside the default and the judgment on the grounds of irregularity, which motion was heard and overruled by the court, and this appeal followed.

The main question is whether, under the provisions of Comp. Laws Utah 1917, § 6844, the pendency of plaintiff’s motion precluded the entry of the default and judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.