Court of Appeals of Maryland July 1, 1924 (Lookerman v. Eastern Shore Trust Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1924

*341

AdiciNS, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This case was on the docket of the January term and was heard during that term. On motion of appellee a re-argument was granted and heard during the present term. Before the re-argument a motion was made to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the record was not transmitted to this Court “within three months from the, time of the appeal taken” as required by Code, art. 5, see. 6 (Rule 2 of this Court). No such motion was made at or before the previous argument.

In the view we take of the matter it will not be necessary to decide how far, if at all, that omission affects the present motion, as we do not think it ought to have been granted even if it had been made before the former hearing.

Section 40 of article 5 of the Code (Rule 18) provides that no appeal shall be dismissed because the transcript shall not have been transmitted within the time prescribed, if it shall appear to the Court of Appeals that such delay was occasioned by the neglect, omission or inability of the clerk or appellee, but such neglect, omission or inability shall not be presumed, but must be shown by the appellant.

The appeal was taken October 6th, 1923. The record was transmitted to this Court on January 11th, 1924, five or six days after the three months,’ period had expired. It was therefore, under Rule 18, incumbent upon appellant to show that the delay was occasioned by the neglect, omission or inability of the clerk or appellee. Mr. James E. Ellegood, one of appellant’s attorneys, filed an affidavit in this Court, in which it is alleged:

That (and this appears from the docket entries) the time for filing exceptions, was extended by the trial court until December 15th, 1923, because of the delay on the part of the court stenographer in presenting appellant’s counsel with a copy of the testimony; that counsel for appellant instructed the stenographer immediately after the rendering of the judgment to transcribe the testimony .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.