Ohio Supreme Court March 25, 1924, No. 17999. (Stein v. White)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-03-1924
By the Court.
The plaintiffs in error assert that various prejudicial errors of law occurred in the judgment of the Court of Appeals. These alleged errors, according to the plaintiffs in error, involve questions which are substantially as follows:
(1) Will equitable partition be enforced where possession is taken and maintained for 35 years?
(2) Under Section 11901, General Code, does the statute of limitations start to run against a
remainderman
who has knowledge of possession by an adverse claimant?
(3) Are defendants in error estopped by their neglect to protest against the visible and notorious possession of the son and his family, and their improvement of the property, and by their own failure to invoke their remedy under the statute?
(4) Had the probate court jurisdiction over the subject-matter, and was not its apparent jurisdiction under the petition ousted by the answer and the evidence?
(5) Was it error in the court to order the sale of improvements made by plaintiffs in error, on the ground that they constituted part of the estate of the decedent?
Several of these questions are disposed of by
*582
the record. As to the first contention, since there is no finding of facts before us, we cannot tell that the trial courts found that equitable partition had been made. There was evidence to the effect that Samuel M. Dobbs, with the consent of his mother, the life tenant, built a two-room house upon the acre he now claims. The evidence exhibits no express approval upon the part of the other co-tenants.
There is evidence tending to establish that the brothers and sisters at a meeting held after Samuel M. Dobbs had built the two-room house, refused to sign deeds releasing to Samuel Dobbs their interest in this one acre.
The lower courts, therefore, may well have found upon the evidence that equitable partition had not taken place, and this question is not before us.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit