District Court, E.D. New York January 19, 1924 (The Mattie)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-01-1924
INCH, District Judge.
About midday .September 21, 1922, the tug Mattie was towing the scow Roslyn up the Bast River. It was a clear bright day with apparently no wind to speak of or any unusual condition of weather or tide. As one witness said, “It was a fine day.”
The scow was loaded with sand and gravel and was being towed behind the Mattie, by means of hawsers. These hawsers were about 40 feet long and ran from the stern'of the tug to each corner of the bow of the scow.
The tug and scow was proceeding up the East River and running with the tide, which was just beginning to flood. .At Willis ave*999nue, a bridge crosses the river. This bridge bas two draws, one on the west or Manhattan side, and one on the east or Bronx side. Between these two draws in the middle of the bridge and dividing the river into two channels is a rugged stone support, and on the east side and west side of these two so-called channels is a similar stone abutment.
'The scow in question is owned by the libel-ant Cleary Bros., Inc.
The East River at this point is a well-known and busy thoroughfare. It. seems at certain parts of the tide each day a current sets in some distance below the bridge, and this has a tendency to run towards the Manhattan side until a few blocks below the bridge, where it turns and approaches in a diagonal direction the east or Bronx side.
Whether or not this current was running at the time of the accident is disputed; the libelant claiming that the tide had reached a condition, at least one-half hour before the accident, where its effect would be un-notieeable. However, it seems that when the current is running, tug captains prefer to take the west side or Manhattan draw in going up the river.
Apparently the tug Mattie was so proceeding in the direction of the west draw, but then changed her course and endeavored to pass through the east draw.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit